Skip to main content

Give me freedom and see if you can take it back!

 


I had a call from William, a schoolmate, and dear friend, now settled in the U.S. Will has a cute and chubby daughter named Mehreen, aged around 2 years. She was recently in India with her mother. They stayed here for 3 months and this was Mehreen’s first visit to India.

They had a busy schedule as they met relatives and friends and had to travel to different places. The mode of travel was a car. In the U.S. there are strict laws for traveling with a child. The Car needs to have a child seat properly secured if you are to travel with a child. India is a little behind on this front and it is not yet a strict rule to provision for a secure child seat in the car.

Mehreen would have traveled in a car in the U.S. as a toddler and been seated in the child’s seat fastened on the rear seat of the car. In India, she had no such compulsion and could sit, stand and move inside the car. Of course, that is not safe but many cars in India do not have a feature to affix the child seat. So, it is a calculated call Indians take every day while they travel with their kids. Mehreen enjoyed her freedom and liked to be not fastened to the child seat.

After they went back to the U.S. Will called and told me that now it has become a challenge to travel with Mehreen. She just won’t sit on the child’s seat and wants to be freed. She has just had a taste of the freedom she enjoyed in the car in India. This new scarcity of freedom irked her to the extent that it is impossible to quiet her once inside the car.

I discussed with Will that this is a psychological reaction that once a freedom is granted it is difficult to take it back without severe resistance. The case of Russian liberalism in 1991 when Mikhail Gorbachev, then President of the USSR is a testament to this phenomenon.

Gorbachev had announced liberalism in the country and the measures had been received with exceeding appreciation by the masses. There were opponents to the liberal grants including a small group of government officials, the KGB, and the military of the nation which grabbed power through a coup. Gorbachev was house arrested and the matters were taken under control by the group. The first action taken was to roll back the liberal measures and reinstate the old order of restrictions.

The masses came out to the streets leading to violent protests across the country. The detractor officials were spellbound by the public reaction. They probably did not anticipate that by rolling back the freedoms granted they are creating a new scarcity in the minds of people who will not forego their prized possession.

Gorbachev was reinstated and mercy was sought by the detractors. People got their newfound love back.

So Mehreen is reacting the way a Russian reacted to the coup of the military.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kangyatse - Learning the Ropes - 1

The expedition to Kang Yatse 1 and 2 It was a much-anticipated event for me being my first expedition of life post Basic Mountaineering Course and was an introduction to mountaineering. I had been preparing for the expedition after the BMC and was in a fix on whether I  would be able to make it to the team given my official obligations. Getting a leave for 15 days just 50 days after a month-long leave was a challenge. Surprisingly, I was transferred mid-year which displaced me from Gurgaon. Joining a new place, I was not sure if I would get the leaves on the set dates. There was no time to prepare physically and mentally. It was not even known if the organizers were sure about us joining the team as the sanction of leaves from work was to be the deciding factor. It was a tough call to take. All the haphazard planning and anticipation culminated in getting leaves sanctioned on time. For Manmeet, it was not much of a hassle and she even got  her confirmation a bit earlier....

Psychological reactance- How you react when your beloved thing is taken away!

  Have you ever wondered how Romeo and Juliet could fall so much in love? Same for Heer and Ranjha, Sassi and Punnu, and other folklore of love. These stories of unbridled love ending in tragedies instead of the divine union have common undercurrents. Their romances were not acceptable to society, particularly their families. Now think of a situation where these guys didn’t have any resistance or interference from their parents or society. Do you think their love would have kindled to the limits of madness? They would have probably got married and then daily life issues that every married couple faces would have been theirs too. It would not even have been a story worth mentioning. Recent experiments show that increased parental interferences and pressures lead to couples acknowledging the greater number of negative traits in their partner apart from becoming more critical but with a caveat, they actually fell more in love. When they are forced to ignore each other, it makes th...